In today’s age of gourmet pet care, the phrase ‘dog’s dinner’ is taking on a whole new meaning. As pet parents increasingly seek the best nutrition for their furry companions, brands like Ollie and Freshpet are rising to the occasion.

The pet food industry has witnessed revolutionary changes in recent years, with many turning to premium brands in the quest for the best. Ollie and Freshpet are two names that have been on the tip of every dog lover’s tongue, but which one truly deserves the top spot in your pantry?

Let’s find out.

Ollie Vs. Freshpet Dog Food

Brief Background

Founded with a mission to feed dogs as family, Ollie delivers fresh, custom meals directly to dog owners. Prioritizing transparent sourcing and high-quality ingredients, Ollie has been a game-changer in the world of canine cuisine.

Making waves with its refrigerated dog food range, Freshpet emphasizes natural ingredients without preservatives. Their commitment? Fresh, real food that our pets deserved all along.

Ingredients and Nutritional Profile: A Closer Look

Ollie: Source of Ingredients

Ollie prides itself on sourcing high-quality ingredients, ensuring traceability from the farm to the bowl. Their proteins, including beef, chicken, turkey, and lamb, are primarily sourced from trusted U.S. farms.

Ollie Dog Food

Some ingredients, like certain fish, might be imported but always meet their rigorous standards.

Nutritional Composition:

  • Proteins: Ollie’s meals are rich in high-quality lean meats, providing essential amino acids crucial for muscle development, immune function, and overall health.
  • Vegetables: Ingredients like peas, spinach, and carrots not only provide vital vitamins and minerals but also offer dietary fiber for digestive health.
  • Fats: Healthy fats, including fish oil and flaxseed, ensure a balanced omega-3 and omega-6 profile, promoting skin and coat health.
  • Vitamins and Minerals: Ollie’s meals are fortified with necessary vitamins and chelated minerals, enhancing nutrient absorption and supporting all life stages’ needs.

No Fillers or Artificial Additives: Ollie avoids common fillers like corn, wheat, and soy. They also refrain from using artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, ensuring your pup’s meal remains as natural as possible.

Freshpet: Source of Ingredients:

Freshpet emphasizes transparency in its sourcing process. Their primary proteins – chicken, beef, and fish – come from carefully vetted farms and fisheries that adhere to responsible practices.


Nutritional Composition:

  • Proteins: Freshpet offers a diverse protein profile, from traditional sources like beef and chicken to more novel ones like bison. Such variety can be beneficial for dogs with specific protein sensitivities.
  • Vegetables: Ingredients such as green beans, spinach, and sweet potatoes not only enrich the meal with vitamins but also add antioxidant properties essential for combating cellular damage.
  • Grains and Grain-Free Options: While Freshpet has some grain-inclusive recipes using brown rice or barley, they also provide grain-free alternatives catering to dogs with grain sensitivities.
  • Beneficial Add-ons: Freshpet often incorporates ingredients like cranberries for urinary health, eggs for additional protein, and salmon oil for a healthy omega profile.

No Processed Wheat or Soy: Freshpet refrains from using heavily processed grains, focusing on whole ingredients. Their avoidance of soy, a common allergen for some dogs, also speaks to their commitment to quality.

Comparative Overview:

Both Ollie and Freshpet prioritize offering nutritious, whole-food-based meals for dogs. Ollie’s strength lies in its customization, allowing pet parents to tailor meals based on their dogs’ unique requirements. This approach ensures that every bite is optimized for an individual dog’s health needs.

On the other hand, Freshpet’s variety and commitment to freshness cater to a broad audience, especially those seeking readily available, off-the-shelf premium dog food.

For those seeking a custom approach, Ollie has the edge, but Freshpet’s diverse product range and accessibility make it an equally compelling choice.

Product Variety and Options

From chicken to beef and even vegetarian options, Ollie’s diverse range caters to all dog breeds and sizes. Their diet variety ensures every dog, from a Chihuahua to a Great Dane, has something to relish.

On the other hand, with a plethora of choices including grain-free, high-protein, and even gourmet recipes, Freshpet is perfect for those looking for variety in flavors and nutrients.

Price and Value

Although on the higher side, Ollie’s subscription model can offer savings, especially for regular buyers. The premium ingredients justify the price tag.

Available at many local stores, Freshpet offers competitive pricing. The convenience of grabbing it during regular grocery runs adds to its value.

Comparative Overview: While Ollie gives the bespoke feel, Freshpet scores on convenience and accessibility.

Advantages and Disadvantages: Diving Deeper into Ollie and Freshpet

Ollie Dog Food Advantages:

Tailored Nutrition:

One of the standout features of Ollie is its ability to tailor meals to the specific needs of individual dogs. By taking into account factors like age, weight, breed, activity level, and any special health considerations, Ollie ensures that every bite your dog consumes is optimized for their health.

High-Quality Sourcing:

Ollie maintains strict standards when it comes to ingredient sourcing. They collaborate with trusted farms that prioritize humane treatment and sustainable practices. This not only ensures high nutritional value but also promotes ethical consumption.

Convenient Subscription Model:

The subscription model Ollie offers isn’t just about getting regular food deliveries. It’s about peace of mind, ensuring that your pet never runs out of food. The regular deliveries can be paused, adjusted, or canceled based on your needs, making it adaptable and user-friendly.

Freshpet Dog Food Advantages:

Wide Availability:

Unlike most premium dog food brands, Freshpet has secured its place in a multitude of retail stores across the U.S. This broad availability means you can pick up a pack during your regular grocery shopping, making it exceptionally convenient.

Fresh, Preservative-Free Recipes:

Freshpet’s commitment to freshness isn’t just in the name. Their recipes avoid traditional preservatives, leaning instead on natural preservation methods like refrigeration. This guarantees that your pet is consuming food that’s as close to its natural state as possible.

Diverse Product Range:

From different protein sources to grain-inclusive or grain-free options, Freshpet offers a wide variety of recipes. This diversity ensures that even pets with specific dietary requirements or sensitivities have something suitable in Freshpet’s lineup.

Ollie’s Disadvantages:

Slightly Pricier:

Quality often comes at a price. Ollie’s commitment to premium ingredients and tailored nutrition can mean their meals are a bit more expensive than generic, off-the-shelf brands.

Requires Subscription for Best Prices:

While Ollie’s subscription model offers several advantages, there’s a flip side. To get the most competitive prices and the full benefits of their service, one needs to commit to their subscription. This might not be ideal for those averse to regular commitments or those with fluctuating financial situations.

Freshpet’s Disadvantages:

Limited Customization:

While Freshpet offers a diverse range of products, they don’t provide the same level of personal tailoring as Ollie. This means if your pet has very specific dietary needs, you might have to look a bit harder to find the perfect Freshpet recipe.

Refrigeration Necessary Post-Opening:

Freshpet’s commitment to preservative-free recipes means that once you open a package, it needs to go into the fridge. While this isn’t a major inconvenience for most, it does mean you need to remember to use it quickly to ensure freshness and avoid wastage.

Both Ollie and Freshpet come with their sets of advantages and drawbacks. The right choice largely depends on your priorities as a pet owner, whether it’s customization, convenience, cost, or a balance of these factors.


Ollie is perfect for those seeking specific dietary plans for their pets, especially with unique health needs while Fresh Pet dog food is best for those wanting a fresh, off-the-shelf solution without the fuss of custom meal plans.

FAQs: A Deeper Dive into Ollie vs. Freshpet

Is Ollie or Freshpet better for puppies?


One of Ollie’s standout features is its ability to customize meals based on a dog’s specific profile. When you sign up, they ask a variety of questions about your dog – its breed, weight, activity level, age (including if it’s a puppy), and any allergies or dietary restrictions. This information allows Ollie to craft meals tailored to a puppy’s rapid growth and development.

As puppies have unique nutritional needs, such as higher protein and fat requirements, this customization can be incredibly beneficial. Additionally, the variety in Ollie’s meals can help puppies get accustomed to different flavors, which can be valuable in preventing them from becoming picky eaters.


Freshpet does have dedicated lines for puppies, emphasizing high-quality protein sources and essential vitamins and minerals necessary for bone growth, cognitive development, and overall health.

Their meals are crafted to be palatable, ensuring young pups are eager to eat at every mealtime. While they may not offer the same level of individual customization as Ollie, their ready-to-purchase convenience can be a draw for many pet parents.

Both brands prioritize puppy health, but if you’re looking for more tailored nutrition, Ollie could have the edge. However, for ease and speed, Freshpet is a worthy contender.

How do the subscription models for Ollie compare to buying Freshpet in-store?


Ollie operates primarily as a subscription service. Once you’ve provided details about your dog and chosen your recipes, Ollie calculates a meal plan and delivers right to your door at regular intervals. The benefits include:

  • Convenience: Regular deliveries mean you won’t run out of dog food unexpectedly.
  • Cost-Effective: By subscribing, you often get meals at a discounted rate compared to one-time purchases.
  • Flexibility: Modify, pause, or cancel your subscription as needed, giving you control over your orders.


Freshpet, available in many retail stores, offers the advantage of immediacy. If you run out of dog food, you can quickly drive to a nearby store and grab a pack. Some benefits include:

  • No Commitment: Purchase only when needed without being tied to a subscription.
  • See Before Buying: Physically inspect products before purchasing.
  • Variety: Easily switch between different Freshpet products based on availability.

If you value automated, tailored deliveries, Ollie’s subscription is a boon. However, for those who prefer in-person shopping and the flexibility to buy on-the-fly, Freshpet shines.

Are there any recalls or safety concerns associated with either brand?

Product recalls in the pet food industry can be concerning. While they do indicate that a problem was identified, they also show that the company is taking steps to address and rectify the issue.


Ollie has maintained a strong reputation for quality and safety. Their direct-to-consumer model means they have a close relationship with their products from production to delivery, ensuring a high level of oversight. Always refer to Ollie’s official website or trusted pet food recall databases for the latest information.


Freshpet’s commitment to fresh, preservative-free food has made it a favorite among many. They’ve been proactive about quality control, but like all brands, it’s essential to stay informed about any potential issues. Always check Freshpet’s official site or trusted industry websites for current recall information.

Both Ollie and Freshpet prioritize the safety and well-being of pets. It’s crucial for pet owners to stay informed and regularly check for updates, ensuring their pets get the safest, healthiest food possible.

Remember, in the dynamic world of pet food, staying updated is crucial. Both brands have showcased commitment to quality, but individual preferences and pets’ unique needs will always play a significant role in the best choice for you and your furry friend.


In the great “Ollie dog food vs Freshpet” debate, the winner truly depends on what you and your canine companion prioritize. If custom nutrition is key, Ollie might be your pick. For off-the-shelf freshness and variety, Freshpet is hard to beat.

Always remember, the best choice is what keeps those tails wagging!

Read also:

Categories: Comparison


Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

close X

Try The Best Rated Dog Food On Amazon

Ancient grains like grain sorghum, millet, quinoa and chia seed are naturally high in fiber and rich in protein. Unchanged for thousands of years, different grains provide various nutrients such as vitamins, minerals, antioxidants and omega fatty acids.